Wednesday, March 9, 2011

To Donate or Not To Donate...That Is The Question...

In response to Jenny Beers's question, "Who is more inclined to donate money, people who have a lot of it or people who have just enough to get by?"...

     In my experience, it seems that those who give the most are those who do not have that much at all. It seems somewhat ironic that the "poor" would help the "poor" so to speak, but it makes perfect sense. Those who do not have much understand that it is very difficult to be in that position, and therefore are motivated to help to the best of their ability. It is kind of how a person is likely to give to a cancer research foundation if they have a family member who has had, or has, the disease. However, it appears that they are usually more apt to help causes in other ways that giving cash directly. Many people who start and run organizations volunteer their time to help raise money through certain events, or help to plan fundraising strategies. Those who can barely get by might offer to cook a meal or provide shelter to someone who needs it desperately. Thus, the more that I think about it, the more that I realize that those who barely have enough are not so likely to give money, but rather donate their time, love, and services.
     So, it seems that those who have a great deal of money are the ones who donate it, though the phrase "a lot of money" can mean many things. It can mean the middle class disposable income, or the funds of the rich. From my observations I have found that it is truly the middle class that donates money the most. This is probably because they are close enough to the working class to understand hardships with money, but close enough to the upper class as well to understand the concept of disposable income. In class, someone mentioned that the rich are very unlikely to give money because of their stinginess. But, I learned something different in my Introduction to Sociology course last semester. The rich are very likely to give large amounts to charities because it is built into the societal expectations of what the rich should do. They are expected to make connections and build business ties through private clubs, donate to charity, and go to prestigious schools. This is why huge charity benefits are often thrown by extremely rich families - they have the money to do so, and the community they reside in expects that of them. So, are you more likely to donate to a cause if you have been through such a situation yourself? Why does it always seem that though you may help others while they are in need, when the time comes for you to get help, no one will give it to you? Are you more likely to be more "charitable" after such a thing happens?

3 comments:

  1. I responded to one of your questions (Why does it always seem that though you may help others when they are in need, when the time comes to get help, no one will give it to you?)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I'll be responding to your question Julia(:

    ReplyDelete
  3. I definitely believe you are more likely to donate to a cause if you have been through a similar situation or have depended on the charity before. I think many people feel they are obligated to, more or less pay, back the charity for everything they did and continue to do. I work at a McDonald’s and we always have the little cans for the Ronald McDonald House put sometimes we sell hands and hearts too. When we do this I get some people who tell me about how much the Ronald McDonald House helped them so they will always donate.

    As for why it seems like when there comes a time when you need help no one is willing I have no idea as to why this is. All I know is it is oober disappointing and annoying. It also causes me to develop a very negative attitude….it makes me think , “that person better not ever ask me for a hand out”. I think it would be interesting to see if there is any research being done or already done on the reason for this.

    I believe the last question ties into your first one as well. Again if you have received helped from someone you are more likely to help them in return. As for whether or not you become more “charitable” if it seems like no one helps I am not so sure this is always the case. Some people may do this because they may think that if they help more and others see that they help more they think they will be respected more and thus get more in return. Or if they develop more of a negative attitude like in the example above they may become less likely to donate.

    Question:

    Why do you think it is that so many people think that in order to be altruistic you have to donate to a charity??

    ReplyDelete